I was very excited to read The Bear until I started it and then I couldn’t wait to just be done with it. The story is horrific but you sort of can’t turn away. Except. Except that it’s written in this childlike voice that matches the young narrator well but is so, so, so distracting. I couldn’t hardly handle it.
I’m fascinated by the story in Island of the Blue Dolphins. A woman is left on an island after everyone else in her community leaves. She survives for nearly twenty years alone until she is picked up and taken to the mainland United States. She subsequently catches a disease and dies within a short period. That sounds like a total spoiler, but it’s all in the story’s introduction. The book itself is about those twenty years on the island. If I had read this as a child, I think I would have loved it. As an adult, I kept waiting to learn about the brief time she spent in the States, but those details never came. It’s still an excellent story and one I’ll be gifting to my young reader friends.
My Week in Books
In her introduction to Scott O’Dell’s novel Island of the Blue Dolphins, Lois Lowry writes, “This is a book about the things most meaningful to young readers: what we are capable of, if called upon; the question of what home is and means; and what our relationship is to the natural world.”
Not only does that fully capture the appeal of Island of the Blue Dolphins, but also, to a lesser extent, The Bear by Claire Cameron, and so many novels I read while younger, such as My Side of the Mountain by Jean Craighead George.
None of us really want to be challenged in some horrific way. We don’t want to be orphaned after a bear attack or left alone on an island. But we want to imagine that, if it actually did happen to us, we would excel.
This post originally appeared on Kate’s Point of View. © Kate. All rights reserved.
Heather
Hmm… I’m thinking I’ll avoid The Bear for awhile. I’m ashamed to say I’ve never read Island. Sounds like I missed out!